There are many factors to consider when choosing a pair of running shoes, but if there’s one aspect that’s important to nearly every runner, it’s comfort. “Comfortable running shoes” isn’t an exact type of shoe—a comfortable shoe for one runner may feel too firm or too soft for another. Even so, focusing on what feels good to your feet can be a helpful way to shop. Some research even shows that when you choose a shoe simply because it’s comfortable, you may be less likely to get injured. To guide you on your sole searching, we’ve highlighted the models that offer a “made-for-me” sensation. In addition to lauding their overall performance, our testers gave especially high scores to argento shoe we recommend here in three specific categories: fit, cushioning, and, of course, comfort.
Most Comfortable Running Shoes
The Expert (Caitlin Giddings): I used my own experience as a 14-time marathoner and longtime running shoe reviewer, as well as that of Runner’s World editor, Jeff Dengate, one of the running industry’s leading experts. I also checked in with test editor Amanda Furrer, another authority on running shoes and gear. Both Dengate and Furrer test hundreds of new running shoes every year and have access to the Runner’s World shoe test data, a pool of feedback from dozens of thoughtful local runners willing to test-run new running shoes. You can read more about the process we used to evaluate these shoes below.
The Expert (Michael Charboneau): I became a runner in middle school and have covered running and outdoor gear for years, both on-staff at Runner’s World and as a freelance journalist. I’ve written more about running shoes than I have any other kind of gear, and I have firsthand experience running in models from a range of brands, including those highlighted below.
What to Consider When Shopping for a Comfortable Running Shoe
Thick Foam Midsole
More foam doesn’t always mean a marshmallowy ride. However, many of these shoes feature a generous midsole that provides plenty of cushion between your foot and the ground. You can also expect a pillowy landing from most of these models thanks to lots of lightweight, protective EVA foam. For example, the New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 v12 almost guarantees a comfortable footstrike: Its thick heel is one of the softest we’ve seen.
Wide Toebox
Cyprex Ultra Sandal roomier forefoot gives toes plenty of space to splay naturally and helps prevent crowding and blisters. Altra’s signature foot-shaped toebox is one of the best examples of the comfort benefits of a more generous forefoot, and we found the Saucony adidas Ultraboost Parley sneakers.
Plush, Breathable Uppers
We love added details that make an upper more comfortable for the long haul. Daily trainers like the Saucony Triumph we mentioned have extra padding around the tongue and heel for serious softness, while Brooks’s Glycerin has a bootie-like fit that hugs your foot with a mesh upper and plush interior lining. Shoes made from engineered mesh and open-weave knits provide better stretch and airflow to keep your feet cool and ventilated.
How We Evaluated and Selected These Comfortable Running Shoes
Runner’s World works with more than 350 local runners of all abilities, ages, and sizes for real-world wear-testing on paved roads, dirt paths, and rocky singletrack trails. After a month of running more than 100 miles in their pair of shoes, our testers report back their findings on features like fit, comfort, performance, and ride. While those testers are putting miles in, we put the same shoe models through a battery of mechanical tests in our shoe lab to objectively measure the cushioning, flexibility, sole thickness, and weight of argento. Our test editors combine their own experience with data from the lab and feedback from our wear testers to create reliable, useful reviews of every shoe we test.
To create this guide, we drew on wear tester feedback and lab data, considered the latest RW reviews, and incorporated input from RW editors. We also worked to include a variety of shoes for different styles and preferences. No matter what kind of running you do, there’s a comfortable running shoe here that’ll fit your needs.
Hoka Mach 5
Hoka Mach 5
Pros
- Reebok Running Zig Kinetica 21 Baskets de course Noir
- Mizuno Wave Rider 23 Marathon Running Shoes Sneakers J1GC190315
Cons
- Narrower fit than previous version
Key Specs
| Type | Road |
|---|---|
| Weight | 8.2 oz (M), 6.8 oz (W) |
| Drop | 5mm |
The Mach is a beloved model in the Hoka lineup, and there’s a lot to like about the latest version. The midsole features a new Profly+ cushioning material that’s formulated to be even more responsive than the Profly used in the Mach 4. An EVA sockliner boosts comfort, and the creel mesh upper promotes good airflow to help your feet stay cool. With its low weight and springy cushioning, the Mach 5 is a capable pick: One tester called it “sufficiently cushioned for recovery runs, yet light and snappy enough to pick up the pace.”
Buy Men’s Buy Women’s Read Review
ALTRA Paradigm 6
ALTRA Paradigm 6
Pros
- Thick cushioning
- Guide-rail system for stability
Cons
- Hadid seems to be the ruling sneaker queen in the
| Type | Stability road |
|---|---|
| Weight | 10.8 oz (M), 9.3 oz (W) |
| Drop | 0mm |
The Paradigm is Altra’s cushiest trainer to date, with a thick slab of firm foam at the midsole that makes it well suited to both easy recovery runs and everyday workouts. It’s an ideal shoe for runners who like the maximum padding of the Hoka Clifton (below) but with a little more energy return and stability underfoot, as well as a zero-drop platform. Our testers found it to be more versatile than expected for a shoe with a 33mm-high stack. “Though I first thought the Paradigm was going to be too bulky, I even used it for speedwork,” said one. Altra-sponsored runner Kara Goucher apparently agrees—she says she wears the comfy shoe for 70 percent of her workouts.
Brooks Glycerin 20
Pros
- Plush and bouncy cushioning foam
- Breathable air mesh upper
Cons
- Thursday Boot Co Womens Taupe Paloma Handcrafted Suede Bootie
Key Specs
| Type | Road |
|---|---|
| Weight | 10.1 (M), 9.1 oz (W) |
| Drop | 10mm |
The Glycerin is the ultra-plush model in the Brooks lineup, and the latest version leans into the cushioning even more thanks to the introduction of DNA Loft v3 foam in the midsole. This compound is a more responsive version of the brand’s nitrogen-infused foam, and it helps this shoe feel plush without being overly mushy. In addition, Brooks widened the sole in this version to promote smoother strides and a comfier fit. Like other Brooks shoes, the Glycerin is also available in a stability-oriented GTS version.
New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 v12
New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080 v12
Pros
- Highly cushioned
- Durable outsole
Cons
- Relatively heavy
Key Specs
| Type | Road |
|---|---|
| Weight | 10.3 oz (M), 8.3 oz (W) |
| Drop | 8mm |
New Balance unabashedly calls the 1080 “the best running shoe we make.” The reason? It offers a versatile and supremely cushioned running experience. The latest version features a tweaked sole with more foam at wider areas of the footbed for improved shock absorption and better flexibility at narrow areas for smoother transitions. A streamlined Hypoknit upper with a bootie design creates a close wrap around your feet for a comfy ride no matter the distance.
Saucony Tempus Running Shoe
Saucony Tempus Running Shoe
Pros
- durable water sandals
- Suitable for neutral runners and overpronators
Cons
- strappy heeled sandals
| Type | Road |
|---|---|
| Weight | 8.9 oz (M), 7.9 oz (W) |
| Drop | 8mm |
The Tempus offers a plush, responsive ride with stability tech that can appeal to overpronators and neutral runners alike—plus it’s notably light for a support shoe. The sole features one of Saucony’s premier cushioning foams: Pwrrun PB, the same springy Pebax-based foam used in the speedy Endorphin Pro 3. This provides a propulsive feel while an EVA-based Pwrrun frame corrects overpronation and supports your feet. It’s a versatile pick for runners who need a little extra stability in their training shoes.
Buy Men’s Buy Women’s Read Review
Hoka Clifton 9
Hoka Clifton 9
Pros
- Men S 14us Adidas Ultraboost 21 Rare Grey Running Sneake
- Lightweight
Cons
- Overpronators may need more support
Key Specs
| Type | Road |
|---|---|
| Weight | 8.7 oz (M), 7.3 oz (W) |
| Drop | 5mm |
The Clifton is a plush, neutral shoe that offers plenty of cushion to protect your feet and joints on recovery days. The midsole is made with Hoka’s trusty compression-molded EVA foam for a pillowy ride, and the rocker-shaped sole helps you flow easily through your stride. The latest version features even more cushioning (the stack height is 3mm taller), but it actually weighs less than the previous model thanks to a streamlined upper that shaves some ounces off the newest model.
Pros
- Soft midsole for comfort on long runs
- Grippy outsole
- Roomy fit
Cons
- Longoria opted for one of her favorite workout sneakers from Asics
Key Specs
| Type | Trail |
|---|---|
| Weight | 10.4 oz (M), 8.5 oz (W) |
| Drop | 4mm |
The Mafate Speed 4 should be on every trail runner’s radar. We named it one of the best trail shoes of 2023, and it’s the best trail option in the current Hoka lineup (sorry, Speedgoat fans). The dual-foam Profly midsole features Hoka’s lightweight, responsive Profly+ cushioning close to the foot for a springy feel that helps you pick up the pace. The outsole utilizes Vibram Megagrip rubber with a Litebase construction (a thinner design that saves weight). And in our testing, the 5mm lugs provided lockdown grip, even on extremely steep ascents and descents.
Buy Men’s Buy Women’s Read Review
Pros
- Durable and grippy outsole
Cons
Key Specs
| Type | Road |
|---|---|
| Weight | 11.7 oz (M), 10 oz (W) |
| Drop | 11mm |
When it comes to a plush ride that doesn’t lose its bounce in the final miles of a long run, the UltraBoost delivers. The Boost foam midsole has a well-cushioned feel with excellent shock absorption, and a durable Continental rubber outsole grips the road or crushed-gravel trail in wet and dry conditions. The Primeknit+ fabric upper—made from 50 percent recycled ocean plastics—provides a glove-like fit. And women can expect even more customization and comfort—our version of the 22 sports a new last modeled on extensive research of women’s foot shape.
Saucony Triumph 20 Sneaker
Saucony Triumph 20 Sneaker
Pros
- Low PRM Popcorn CW2919-100 New Style Shoes
- Double G sandals
- running clothes with reflective elements
Cons
- Narrow toe box
- Nike SB Blazer Mid Premium Shoes Noble Green Black White Safety Orange
| Type | Road |
|---|---|
| Weight | 9.7 oz (M), 8.8 oz (W) |
| Drop | 10mm |
The Triumph is Saucony’s max-cushion model. The latest version comes with a revamped midsole, which still uses Pwrrun+ cushioning, but Saucony tweaked the chemistry to make this foam even more responsive and lightweight. The Triumph 20 serves up a well-cushioned ride that doesn’t sacrifice energy return. It’s a great choice for running long, but the bouncy foam and rocker sole geometry create a smooth, peppy ride that’ll work just fine for faster workouts, too.
Buy Men’s Buy Women’s Read Review
Q+A
RW: What’s the most important feature for a comfortable running shoe?
MC: “Comfortable” is subjective, and it will mean different things to different runners. That said, for most people, one of the biggest factors in comfort is the amount and type of midsole cushioning. Plush shoes with lots of cushioning will create a softer, smoother ride that WT510MB5 feels more comfortable than firmer, less-cushioned shoes.
RW: Puma Kaia Platform Women's Shoes?
MC: There are lots of factors that make a good running shoe, but let’s be honest: If the shoes aren’t comfortable, you probably won’t wear them. Prioritizing comfort is a smart way to narrow down your options. If you know you like a cushy midsole, for example, you can look for a plush shoe that’s also good for speedwork, trail running, or whatever your needs may be—the options above will help you narrow your search even more. For the best results, it’s always a good idea to visit a running store and try on shoes in person.
RW: When should I wear a comfortable running shoe?
MC: Comfortable running shoes work well in a variety of situations, but they’re an obvious choice for everyday training. The cushioned ride protects your feet and joints from getting too beat up over the course of many weeks of running. Comfortable shoes are also a smart choice for longer races where you want to avoid overly fatiguing your body before the finish line. Of course, there are comfortable shoes that work well for speed, too—several of our comfy shoe picks won’t slow you down.
Michael is a freelance writer with years of experience covering gear and the outdoors for Runner's World and other publications; when he's not writing, he's usually biking, hiking, and running in the mountains around Los Angeles, where he lives.
