Most Popular Footwear
Save $50.01

Sale price$99.99
Regular price$150.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X More v4, Marine Blue/Cosmic Rose, 8.5 B MediumNew Balance
Save $65.01

Sale price$99.99
Regular price$165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Grey Matter/Silver Metallic, 7 D WideNew Balance
Save $65.01

Sale price$99.99
Regular price$165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Grey Matter/Silver Metallic, 7.5 D WideNew Balance
Save $65.01

Sale price$99.99
Regular price$165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Grey Matter/Silver Metallic, 11 D WideNew Balance
Save $65.01

Sale price$99.99
Regular price$165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Black/Phantom, 9.5 D WideNew Balance
Save $65.01

Sale price$99.99
Regular price$165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Inkwell/Calcium, 10.5 D WideNew Balance

Second Try Footwear
Relay sources fit-based returns, surplus inventory & footwear in imperfect boxes from authorized retailers and leading brands. Our footwear is practically perfect with zero-mileage normally hidden in warehouses and fulfillment centers.
Learn MoreFresh Listings
Save $60.01

Sale price$99.99
Regular price$160.00
Women's On The Roger Clubhouse Pro, White/Lima, 9.5 B MediumOn
Save $60.01

Sale price$99.99
Regular price$160.00
Men's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v12, Black/Thunder/White, 10.5 B NarrowNew Balance
Save $30.01

Sale price$109.99
Regular price$140.00
Men's Mens New Balance XC Seven v4, Pixel Green, 10 D Medium 21, Reflex Blue/White, 9 D MediumMizuno
Save $90.01

Sale price$109.99
Regular price$200.00
Women's New Balance 1540v4, Turtledove/Silver Moss, 10.5 B MediumNew Balance
Certified Pre-Owned Footwear
We take the same care and attention you’d expect from CARMAX and apply it to performance footwear. Each pair is thoroughly inspected, cleaned, and ready to run, giving you all the benefits of new shoes without the price tag. Comes with a warranty too. Who says only vehicles deserve a second try?
SHOP PRE-OWNED
Footwear Under $100
Save $50.01

Sale price$99.99
Regular price$150.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X More v4, Marine Blue/Cosmic Rose, 8.5 B MediumNew Balance
Save $65.01

Sale price$99.99
Regular price$165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Grey Matter/Silver Metallic, 7 D WideNew Balance
Save $65.01

Sale price$99.99
Regular price$165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Grey Matter/Silver Metallic, 7.5 D WideNew Balance
Save $65.01

Sale price$99.99
Regular price$165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Grey Matter/Silver Metallic, 11 D WideNew Balance
Save $65.01

Sale price$99.99
Regular price$165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Black/Phantom, 9.5 D WideNew Balance
Save $65.01

Sale price$99.99
Regular price$165.00
Women's New Balance Fresh Foam X 1080v14, Inkwell/Calcium, 10.5 D WideNew Balance
Save $20.01

Sale price$49.99
Regular price$70.00
Men's New Balance XC Seven v4, Pixel Green, 10 D MediumNew Balance
Save $20.01

Sale price$49.99
Regular price$70.00
Men's New Balance XC Seven v4, Pixel Green, 11.5 D MediumNew Balance
Save $20.01

Sale price$49.99
Regular price$70.00
Men's New Balance XC Seven v4, Pixel Green, 6 D MediumNew Balance







































